help

Birthday Party

More Occasions

Customer Care

Orders placed now
should ship on:

April 25th*

* Most orders placed by 12 Noon PT Mon-Fri will ship within 2 business days.

GET 10% OFF! Join our email list for exclusive deals & inspiration! JOIN NOW

Milk & Cookies Birthday Party Theme - All Items

Displaying 1 to 31 (of 31 products)

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Black Candle Tin Favors

$4.50

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Candle Favors

$3.00

Made in the USA

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Cupcake Wrappers

$0.79

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Fill In Thank You Cards

$0.99

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Gold Tin Candle Favors

$4.50

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Goodie Bags

~~Regular price: $15.99~~
Sale price: $11.99

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Invitations

~~Regular price: $1.99~~
Sale price: $1.49

Square or Rounded Corner

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Petite Invitations

$0.99

Square or Rounded Corner

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Recipe Card

$0.75

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Return Address Labels

$4.50

30 Labels per Sheet

Milk & Cookies - Birthday Party Thank You Cards

~~Regular price: $1.25~~
Sale price: $0.99

Milk & Cookies - Custom Birthday Party Favor Tins

$1.50

Available in Three Sizes

Milk & Cookies - Custom Birthday Party Treat Bag Topper

$0.99

Milk & Cookies - Custom Rectangle Birthday Party Sticker/Labels

$4.50

18 stickers per sheet

Milk & Cookies - Hershey Kiss Birthday Party Sticker Labels

$4.50

108 - 0.75" Round Stickers Per Sheet!

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Banners

$21.95

60 x 12 inch Indoor/Outdoor

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Candy Bar Wrappers

$0.93

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Candy Jar

$2.25

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Card Stock Favor Tags

$7.25

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Favor Boxes

$1.95

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Magnet Favors

$2.50

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Mini Candy Bar Wrappers

$4.50

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Mint Tins

$1.50

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Place Cards

$0.65

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Placemats

$1.25

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Pocket Mirror Favors

~~Regular price: $3.50~~
Sale price: $2.95

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Rounded Corner Stickers

$4.50

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Wall Art

~~Regular price: $9.99~~
Sale price: $6.95

Milk & Cookies - Personalized Birthday Party Water Bottle Labels

$0.99

Milk & Cookies - Round Personalized Birthday Party Sticker Labels

$4.50

9 sizes available

Milk & Cookies - Square Personalized Birthday Party Sticker Labels

$4.50

3 sizes available

Displaying 1 to 31 (of 31 products)

Create a unique theme for your child's first birthday! This milk and cookies birthday party theme is a cute option for both boys and girls. Set against a tan background, it features a chocolate chip polka dot trim. A mixing bowl, cookie jar and glass of iced cold milk add a delectable finishing touch.